A Visalia woman is suing her former employer–WinCo Holdings, Inc.–for alleged discrimination and unlawful dismissal based on her status as a transgender person.
Wrongful Termination Alleged
The lawsuit, filed on behalf of Carlee MacRae by Visalia attorney Brett Abbott, also alleges WinCo engaged in a number of other violations of state employment law that amount to unfair business practices. The suit lists a series of 10 complaints against the Idaho-based grocery chain. WinCo operates stores locally in Visalia–where MacRae worked–as well as in Fresno and Bakersfield.
In addition to allegations of unfair treatment because of her gender, MacRae’s suit also alleges her managers at WinCo further discriminated against her because of her acute depression, and did not make accommodations for MacRae following debilitating knee surgeries. Management also allegedly engaged in “jury duty” retaliation, failed to prove paid breaks and eventually fired MacRae because of her gender and her disabilities.
The suit has been assigned to Judge Nathan Ide in the Tulare County Superior Court. An initial hearing is scheduled for 8:30 a.m. on April 22 in Department 2 of the Tulare County Courthouse.
Abbott is currently on vacation and unable to comment on the case. WinCo Holdings, Inc. has yet to respond to a request for comment.
Bathroom in the Back
The suit’s primary complaint regards an ongoing series of allegedly discriminatory incidents–as well as a generally hostile work atmosphere–that WinCo managers not only failed to prevent but also created.
According to the suit, MacRae’s bosses told her to use a bathroom at the back of the store, while other employees were allowed to use more accessible facilities. The practice, according to the suit, caused MacRae to miss breaks and experience a sense of shame. Other employees, the suit states, would taunt MacRae when she walked to the back of the store.
“There he [not she] goes… off to the bathroom again,” was allegedly a frequent comment.
When MacRae began wearing makeup to work, she would often face angry reactions from customers, but again management did not work with MacRae to resolve the situation, the suit alleges.
“You should expect some of that,” MacRae’s managers allegedly told her.
Carlee, not Carl
MacRae’s decision to wear makeup also led, allegedly, to many of the store’s employees questioning her about her sexual orientation, asking if MacRae was “gay now.”
“Do you like boys or girls now?” was also a frequent inquiry, the suit says.
The suit also states management at WinCo “took exception” to MacRae’s request to be called Carlee instead of Carl. Some of MacRae’s supervisors, and fellow employees “bristled” at the idea of addressing MacRae as Carlee, it said.
The treatment of MacRae, the suit says, eventually led her to experience “a complete nervous breakdown” in early 2021, resulting in several months of disability leave. She was eventually fired on August 13, 2021, allegedly as a result of her gender identity and expression, and the resulting health problems.
Jury Duty Retaliation
In addition to the gender-based taunting and discrimination that purportedly led to MacRae’s acute mental health crisis and her eventual loss of employment, WinCo Holdings, Inc.’s local managers are also accused of behaving “maliciously, fraudulently and oppressively” by not rescheduling MacRae’s work periods while she served 10 days of jury duty in early 2021.
The suit alleges MacRae’s supervisors required her to work from 5:30 p.m until midnight daily after already serving from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. as a member of a jury. When MacRae requested time off to fulfill her civic duty as a juror, her supervisors refused, which the suit against them says is an additional violation of employment law.
The refusal to change MacRae’s work schedule, the suit says, was also an additional retaliatory act in reaction to MacRae’s expression of her gender. Abbot says his client’s expression of her gender, the need for workplace accommodation for her disabilities following knee surgery, and her need for medical leave eventually led WinCo Holdings, Inc. to dismiss MacRae.
Unfair Business Practices Alleged
Ultimately, the suit against WinCo Holdings, Inc. also accuses the grocery giant of general violations of various labor laws not directly related to the allegations of gender discrimination.
Specifically, after undergoing corrective knee surgery MacRae was instructed by her physicians to take 10-minute sitting breaks for each hour spent standing. While the suit states that WinCo allowed those breaks, her employer required MacRae to clock off to avoid paying her. When MacRae went on disability leave, her employer “docked (her) attendance points.” The practice was repeated when MacRae took time off under the federal Family Medical Leave Act, the suit says.
Additionally, the suit alleges WinCo Holdings, Inc. regularly deprived MacRae of the paid rest and meal breaks required by state employment law for all workers.
As a whole, these violations, if they are substantiated, amount to unfair business practices that are prohibited by state law, the suit says. It describes the alleged behavior as “unfair, unlawful and harmful to plaintiff, to the general public and defendant’s competitors.”
“Accordingly, plaintiff (MacRae) seeks to enforce important rights affecting the public interest, …” the suit states.
The suit seeks damages for lost earnings, as well as a punitive award.
9 thoughts on “WinCo facing transgender discrimination lawsuit”
(Commenter ID is a unique per-article, per-person commenter identifier. If multiple names have the same Commenter ID, it is likely they are the same person. For more information, click here.)
That place went to shit when she took it over…
When who took over?
Seems like she has string evidence if she has dates written down and management didn’t address this. Who asks these questions to employee? Personally after going through a harassment video for El Pollo Loco and the rules you have to follow for trans pronouns I don’t think I can do it. I’m going to call everyone IT NOW OF DAYS!!
Win co story that not women that a men
It shouldn’t matter whether it’s a woman or a man, people need to be treated fairly and equally regardless…
SOOO tired of this.. Special treatment should not be given to ANYONE!!! Who cares what your SEXUAL preference is, I or anyone else does not NEED TO KNOW ABOUT IT!! I, being a female employee would feel highly disrespected if I was made to share a bathroom with someone that had a penis!! I don’t care if you identify as a man, women, dog or cat if you have something dangling between your legs YOU DO NOT BELONG IN THE WOMENS BATHROOM!!! So sick of these people suing businesses because they do not cater to their depression, sexual orientation, etc. If you have problems get a WORK FROM HOME JOB and quit trying to make life harder for people who actually have to WORK EVERY FRICKEN DAY REGARDLESS OF LIFES PROBLEMS!!
The issue is not a penis! Did we read the same article?
Absolutely agree NOONE should have to share a restroom w/the opposite sex…reality is YOU ARE WHAT YOU WERE BORN AT BIRTH…PERIOD! Altho I can’t stand Winco as most of the employees are very rude the prices aren’t that great & the meat has odd taste to it so I quit shopping there long time ago I think alot of restrictions are put on businesses regarding employees but then again NOONES making employees stay at a job that doesn’t fit their needs. The employee made the choice to identify as another gender why should anyone have to make changes to fit their needs?
First of all Carl is male. I don’t care what he identifies as and neither should WinCo. Carl’s presence in this business created chaos with management, employees, customers and vendors. Doesn’t Winco have a reasonable expectation to have the job performed as described in their job description? Creating chaos in the workplace and misrepresenting your gender on the employment application are not part of that description. The transgender issue is polarizing the people of this country to the point of having authoritive members of society calling for the murder of anyone who does not support it. It’s a fad and supported by the greed of the medical community. And here is what no one seems to believe but they should. We are all the creation of God.. He created man and woman. There are no other genders. If you feel your the other gender, you and your doctor should find out if you have hormonal imbalances, then correct them before you destroy your life now and your life after you pass.